What exactly are Sulphites?

If you’re in the UK, or even anywhere else within the EU, you’ll have no doubt noticed the small sentence on your wine’s label which says “Contains Sulphites”. Many people worry about such declarations, as they assume it means someone’s been dabbling with the chemistry set and you’re about to sit down to a glass of bubbling E numbers haphazardly mixed with grape juice. Clearly, this is not the case. If you’ve been keeping an eye out, you’ll notice that this declaration is made on all bottles of wine which you can buy. So, let’s try and answer some common questions.

Firstly, what exactly are sulphites? Sulphites are any compound which contains the chemical Sulphur dioxide. The statement on the label has been mandatory since November 2005, when new regulations necessitated the declaration of any additives to wine. The vague declaration is not, in itself, a particularly useful guide to what’s going on, however. There are maximum levels, yet the declaration doesn’t tell you whether your wine contains a bare minimum or the very maximum.

Secondly, why are they in my wine? To put it simply, they are a preservative. I’m not talking microwave meal/ freezer food preservative, however. Sulphites allow wine to age, and wines with absolutely no added sulphites would be unlikely to age more than even a few months. Even in wine where no preservatives have been added at all, sulphur is still present to the tune of 10mg per litre as it is a natural by-product of the fermentation process. Sulphur dioxide serves as an anti-microbial agent which helps to limit the growth of potentially ruinous yeasts and bacteria in wine. It is also an antioxidant which prevents browning by preserving the colour of the grape skins in the wine. White wine generally contains larger amounts of added Sulphur Dioxide as it does not contain as many anti-oxidants from the grape skins as red does.

Sulphites have been a recognised additive in wine since at least 1487, when the first recorded decree permitting their usage was issued by the Prussian Royal state. At this moment, Sulphur Dioxide was being added to wine in small quantities to permit it to travel for trade or supplies in exploration. Indeed, the practice had been inherited from the Romans, who first developed the trick of burning sulphur candles inside wine barrels before filling them, which was taken up by British and Dutch merchants in turn.

Thirdly, do I have a choice? Broadly, the answer is no. When working at wine shops in the past, I have had people ask for Suplhite-free wine and insist that they’d had it before. To be honest, they’ve probably been mis-sold in another shop, with a sales assistant happily telling them exactly what they want to hear in order to get them to the till then out the door. As made clear in the answer to the last question, Sulphites are a natural by-product of the fermentation process which distinguishes wine from grape juice. You cannot drink wine which is totally free from Sulphites. Some Biodynamic and Organic producers commit themselves to using an absolute minimum of additives and this often means lower levels of Sulphur dioxide. If you’re dead set on trying to avoid them, you’d be best to go for organic or biodynamic red wines.

A very tiny minority of people are sensitive to Sulphites, as with just about any other substance on earth. It can give people migraines and skin conditions and even worsen Asthma. As someone who is asthmatic, I can attest this has never bothered me. If you are affected, laying off the wine is sadly the only realistic answer. The very lowest quality of wine may also contain an excess of Sulphites, added recklessly to ensure a long shelf-life for bargain basement wines. If you smell something like a burnt match when you open a bottle of wine, it’s probably had a little too much added. However, the use of Stelvin closures now means that this smell can be more common with white wines with no fault, as a perfect air seal prevents any gradual dissipation of excess Sulphur dioxide during transit. If it clears after opening, taste the wine as usual and determine any faults from the glass, not the bottle. As always, drink better and smarter and you’re less likely to run into problems.

Basically, there’s no need to panic. Sulphites appear in all wines and you should only worry if you’re drinking industrially cheap wine or are one of the tiny minority with a dietary sensitivity. Best get drinking up!

Bargain Hunt: House Wines and ‘Second Bottle Syndrome’


House wines can be very good indeed. They can also be appalling. The cheapest bottle of wine on the menu plays an interesting role in any restaurant and can say quite a lot about that particular restaurant’s ethos. If you’re in a Michelin starred palace of food, I’ll wager that house wine will be superb. If you’re at a cut-price eatery looking for a quick meal, I’m betting it won’t be. Of course, there’s a world in between, and this is where many of us live. It’s this situation I’d like to briefly mention.

Many people are put off by the notion of buying a house wine, especially if they are eating with friends and want to appear magnanimous. The standard reaction, in this situation, is to opt for the wine directly above the house wine – the next cheapest, as it were.

It is important also to recognise particular reactions that can be manipulated. Again, this is a perfectly valid way of going about things if it has served you well in the past. However, it is also important to realise that it’s not just you doing this and that you haven’t single-handedly cracked the system. Many restaurants place their highest margin wine in this position in order to drive sales with the many people who choose in exactly this way.

Many years ago, when working for the now-defunct Threshers, we were preached to about the virtues of the ‘Power Shelf’. This was the shelf which sat at eye-level amongst a wall full of wine. For the less selective customer a bottle placed here and covered in point-of-sale was the end of the search. Yet again, however, it was also the highest margin bottles placed on this shelf. It didn’t make them bad quality, it just made them high-margin.

Judge yourself whether or not your restaurant is looking to make a statement with a house wine. If it is, so much the better. If it isn’t and you’re looking only at the cost, that’s fine too. The same applies to automatically choosing the second bottle. The point of this post is not to give you hard and fast rules to live by, but merely to point out that some gut decisions can be a bit predictable…

Shelter from the Storm: Wine investment bucks trends


On the back of this year’s successes with en primeur Bordeaux, investment in wine looks to have been a canny haven for cash during troubled times. Two Swiss economists have conducted a long term study which has tracked an index of leading wines against the stock market over recent years. Philippe Masset and Professor Jean-Philippe Weisskopf of Freiburg University limited their study between 1996 and 2009, with an update to the initial report made just last month in March 2010.

Over the course, their study takes in both boom and bust. Whilst charting both the dotcom crash of the early 2000s and the recent banking crisis, their study also includes the booms preceding both bubbles. The results are fairly clear, with a prudent portfolio of wines (based largely around top Bordeaux Chateaux) investors performed far better than their peers in the conventional stock market.

To quote their report:

“Our results show that since 1996, the General Wine Index and particularly first growths wines from top vintages have performed better than equities while showing a lower volatility.”

Some investment is seen to be driven by Chinese capital, with the acquisition of less conventional assets such as wine an important status symbol as well as a prudent investment.

Their report also highlights the importance of diversifying assets during times of economic difficulty, lessening exposure to market volatility. In this vein, the economists’ General Wine Index performed well. During a relative drop in some Share indexes of 47p since the market crash of mid to late 2008, their wine index dropped only 17p. The researchers specifically stated that during times of painful economic downturn “the defensive characteristics of wine are most pronounced.”

It seems that Bordeaux in particular has provided a welcome shelter from the economic storms affecting the global markets. Yet, this isn’t necessarily all positive for your every day wine lover. With investors clamouring to acquire new holdings, prices are inexorably driven higher, as partially shown in this year’s 18% increase in en primeur Bordeaux. Yet, a wealthy industry is, in part, a healthy industry and the market’s thirst for quality wine will hopefully drive investment in both production and the retail sector on this side of the Channel. I may be no closer to picking up vast stocks of first growth bordelais produce, but I’m happy in the knowledge that at least there’ll be a space for it in future markets.

Sus a la fraude! 1907 vindicated?


Fraud is still an enemy of the Midi, it seems. The cause for the great riots of 1907 has proven to be as persistent as a herring . One of the Midi’s largest winemaking cooperatives has met with problems in the Chinese market, where they have been victims of large-scale fraud. Mont Tauch is one of the region’s stars and is responsible for much of the AOC Corbieres and Fitou which we see in the UK market today. It has been active in China since 2007, with steady growth in its sales showing the investment to be a shrewd one.

When rumours began to spread of ridiculously cheap prices, however, authorities were spurred to begin an investigation into the odd market performance. It emerged in February of this year that Chinese counterfeiters have produced some 400,000 bottles of wine which claimed to be AOC Fitou. Although both the bottles and labels bear the logos of the Cooperative and their respective trademarks, the liquid within the bottle was not what it claimed to be. It seems that the liquid within the bottles was actually a very cheap South American wine of greatly inferior quality.

The forgeries were thought to be of good quality and only came to light during a meeting between Mont Tauch representatives and a customer. Nevertheless, authorities feel that they have stopped the flow of counterfeits and that customers in China can once again buy with confidence.

The impact on Mont Tauch’s Chinese business is not thought to be crippling, yet this goes to show the difficulty which fraud can pose. It does seem odd that the South is particularly prone to such forgeries and only strengthens the calls of Southern winegrowers to ensure that regulatory measures ensure wines are genuine and sales are legitimate. As one of my favourite wineries, it seems even more of a shame that such high quality wines were targeted. Nevertheless, now that the problem has been solved Chinese consumers can begin to enjoy some Southern French produce.

Often the ghosts of 1907 haunt the Midi in a negative sense, yet this event goes to show that their story is still relevant to the growers of today. The strict measures employed by the Midi winegrowers to prevent fraud are as important as ever, especially at a time when the Midi’s star is on the rise.

Sublime and ridiculous: Bordeaux 2009 en primeur

The first round of en primeur buying has just finished in Bordeaux for the 2009 vintage. This is where speculators buy the newest release of wine whilst it is still maturing in cask. It’s an interesting time, as the price of the wine can vary massively depending on grower’s reports and the hype which is conjured up around the release.

In short, the 2009 vintage looks to be exciting but inconsistent. Many respected commentators and MWs (Master of Wine) have declared it to be an interesting and potentially great year for some of the hallowed Bordelais vines. Extremely high alcohol levels are being balanced by a complimentary high acidity level which is sitting well with most communes. Success seems to be patchy, however, with quality somewhat uneven amongst producers and perceptions varying amongst critics.

Merlot seems to have suffered from a long ripening season and blends in which this predominates look to be similarly compromised by an overly aggressive alcohol level. Yet some are declaring that this vintage could potentially challenge the much-lauded 2005 release in the most successful Chateaux.

Prices could be high, although restraint has been urged on the part of buyers in an uncertain global financial climate. Prices for 2008 were massively reduced (with stocks for previous vintages remaining unsold amidst a depressed market) and there looks to be a substantial rise in 2009, with the potential for surpassing a more normal level. Estimates place it at about 15% lower than the astronomic prices seen in 2005. Yet, with stocks from previous years still remaining, this may yet prove a false dawn.

Time will tell as the market finds its feet amidst talk of economic recovery. Even top Chateaux are loath to predict the pricing levels for the 2009 vintage, however. The problem lies in the inconsistency of quality – were this vintage an unqualified success across Bordeaux excitement would be through the roof. Yet, with potential pit-falls awaiting investors, a trend of cautious buying could be exacerbated. Sublime for some, ridiculous for those who miss out on what could be a fantastic bargain!